WIDE MOAT STOCKS & COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGES

Checking

 

Paychex, Inc. PAYX

NasdaqBusiness servicesFinancials to Aug 31, 2026 · Updated Nov 11, 2026

On Stock Analysis · affiliate link
PAYX financials
Moat score
70
ROIC
26.0%
Fiscal 2026
P/E
22.6
EV/EBIT
17.2
FCF yield
4.9%
Dividend yield
4.0%
Market cap
$40.9B

Moat ranks

Score rankTied #243 of 396
Durabilitydurable
Market structureCompetitive
Pricing powermoderate

Balance sheet

5/31/26
$BMay '25May '26
Cash1.40.9
Securities0.00.0
Restricted cash0.00.1
Debt5.04.6
Net cash-3.5-3.7
Equity4.13.7
Leverage
Debt / EBITDA
1.52×
Debt / equity
1.23×
Leases (5/31/26)
$74M
Capital
Diluted shares
357M
Book value / share
$10.47
Price / book
10.9×
Net cash / share
−$10.36
Market cap
$40.9B
Enterprise value
$44.5B

Per-share record

Fiscal years and TTM
Scale
$0$5$10$15$20'17'18'19'20'21'22'23'24'2518.09'2618.52TTM
Revenue per shareCash flow per share

Key indicators

Latest: Q1 '27
IndicatorLatestVs year agoLast 8 quarters
Revenue growth5.9%-10.9 pts
Operating margin38.0%+2.8 pts
FCF margin21.5%-20.5 pts
Capex / revenue3.9%-0.7 pts
Client funds at period end$4.3B-12%
WISE early adopter businesses≥50,000––
WISE workforce conversations≥350,000––
Quarterly average client funds$5.4B+0%
Quarterly client-funds earned yield3.7%+0.2 pts

Margins and growth from reported quarters; company KPIs as reported in results releases.

About PAYX

Paychex sells payroll, HR software, advice, retirement administration and PEO services to small and mid-sized employers. It reports one operating segment; these categories divide FY2026 revenue of $6.512 billion.

Revenue mix
Management Solutions 74.8%PEO and Insurance Solutions 22.0%Client funds float (interest on funds held for clients) 3.2%
  • Data Workflow Lockin

    Payroll is the system of record.

  • Service Field Network

    Large HR advisory workforce complements software and improves retention for clients that value hands-on compliance and HR help.

  • Switching Costs General

    PEO relationships embed payroll, HR administration, and benefits processes; switching can be operationally disruptive, supporting retention.

  • Float Prepayment

    Clients pre-fund payroll and tax obligations, and Paychex invests the balances in liquid fixed-income instruments until disbursement.

Timeline
  1. Oct 1, 2026

    Paychex Europe appointed Jürgen Dauk as CEO and Karina Sundbæk as CFO to lead its HR, payroll and workforce software business. Europe supplies about 1% of group revenue, so the change has limited immediate effect on group earnings.

  2. Sep 23, 2026

    Paychex launched WISE Hire for recruiting, available within its payroll platforms or separately; customer hiring decisions still require human control.

  3. Sep 23, 2026

    Paychex raised FY2027 PEO and Insurance revenue growth guidance to 7% to 8% from 6% to 7%, and client-funds interest guidance to $200 million to $210 million from $195 million to $205 million.

  4. Aug 31, 2026 · One-off charge −$9M

    Paycor deal and integration compensation, including replacement awards, severance and retention bonuses. This continues one acquisition integration programme, not a separate recurring annual adjustment. Acquired-intangible amortization remains in reported profit.

  5. Aug 31, 2026 · One-off charge −$100,000

    Paycor deal and integration professional fees and other acquisition costs. This continues one acquisition integration programme, not a separate recurring annual adjustment. Acquired-intangible amortization remains in reported profit.

Financial record

Fiscal year2017201820192020202120222023202420252026TTMTrendChange 2017–26
Per share ($)
Revenue8.709.3410.4311.1911.2012.7013.8214.5815.3918.0918.52+8.5%/yr
Cash flow2.653.533.513.993.484.384.715.245.257.106.31+11.6%/yr
Earnings2.282.752.863.043.033.844.304.674.584.895.06+8.9%/yr
Free cash flow2.362.993.163.613.133.984.294.714.646.335.56+11.6%/yr
Capex0.280.540.360.380.350.400.420.530.610.770.76+11.7%/yr
Dividends1.832.052.292.462.512.753.243.634.004.424.56+10.3%/yr
Book value6.146.527.247.708.148.509.6410.5011.4010.3810.39+6.0%/yr
Diluted shares (M)363362362361362363362362362360357-0.1%/yr
Totals ($B)
Revenue3.23.43.84.04.14.65.05.35.66.56.6+8.4%/yr
Operating income1.31.31.41.51.51.82.02.22.22.52.6+8.0%/yr
Net income0.81.01.01.11.11.41.61.71.71.81.8+8.8%/yr
Free cash flow0.91.11.11.31.11.41.61.71.72.32.0+11.5%/yr
Buybacks0.20.10.10.20.20.10.00.20.10.60.5+15.6%/yr
Dividends0.70.70.80.90.91.01.21.31.41.61.6+10.2%/yr
Net cash0.80.7-0.30.00.10.30.50.5-3.5-3.7–−$4.5B
Margins & returns (%)
Gross margin70.869.968.868.368.770.671.072.072.474.374.4+3.4 pts
Operating margin39.838.236.336.136.039.940.641.239.638.639.2-1.2 pts
Net margin26.229.427.427.227.130.231.132.029.727.027.4+0.8 pts
FCF margin27.232.130.332.327.931.331.032.330.135.030.0+7.8 pts
ROIC50.750.336.640.339.151.352.150.922.226.0–-24.7 pts
Return on equity37.142.239.539.537.245.144.644.540.147.148.7+10.0 pts
Stock pay % of revenue1.11.31.21.21.31.11.31.22.01.51.3+0.4 pts
Capex % of revenue3.35.73.43.43.13.13.13.64.04.34.1+1.0 pts

Change uses 2017 and 2026 only: compound annual growth for amounts, points for margins and returns, and the change in amount for net cash. A dash means no 2017 base. Trend shows the fiscal years.

TTM = four quarters to Aug 31, 2026. Per-share values use diluted weighted shares.ROIC = operating income × (1 − 23.1% tax rate, the company's own over three fiscal years excluding one-offs) ÷ (equity + debt − cash and current securities). Returns show a dash when their base is negative or under 10% of revenue. Free cash flow = operating cash flow − capex. Debt is all borrowings; net cash counts long-term securities and excludes leases.

Moat

Moat scorecard

Moat score70
Strength
Confidence
Structure
Competitive
Durability
durable
Trajectory
stable
Pricing power
moderate
Segments
  • Management Solutions74.8%
    2 claims
  • PEO and Insurance Solutions22.0%
    1 claim
  • Client funds float (interest on funds held for clients)3.2%
    1 claim

Moat claims

Applies to
Management Solutions
Confidence
Durability
durable
Trajectory
stableas of Oct 9, 2026
Why it holds

Payroll is the system of record. Paychex uses payroll data in adjacent HR and retirement modules, which raises workflow switching costs and supports retention.

Why stable

Payroll retention stayed at 82% to 83% through FY2026. WISE now reaches Microsoft 365 and Teams, but its early adoption has not yet shown better retention or sustained organic growth.

Indicators
  • Payroll client retention (lower bound)≥82.0%0.0 pts
  • Payroll client retention (upper bound)≤83.0%0.0 pts
  • Payroll clients~800,0000%
  • Retirement plans130,000+5%
  • WISE early adopter businesses≥50,000
  • WISE identified payroll errors corrected before run day≤90.0%
  • Management Solutions revenue$1.2B+4%
Risks
  • Low-friction cloud onboarding and open APIs reduce switching costs
  • SMB churn / business closures
  • Price-led competition from low-cost payroll SaaS

Profile change log

  1. Oct 9, 2026 · analyst revision

    Replaced the PEO customer-survey provider list with the major US co-employment companies named by First Research. Recalled use, including former customers and mistaken provider names, does not establish market leadership. No provider shares or numerical rank are claimed.

  2. Oct 9, 2026 · analyst revision

    ADP's current filing shows competing AI capabilities at larger global scale. Its revenue-retention measure differs from Paychex's client-count measure, so the percentages do not prove relative customer loyalty. NAPEO's release archive establishes September 17 as the publication date of its 2026 PEO footprint study.

  3. Oct 9, 2026 · analyst revision

    Verified payroll and PEO market sizes and leaders. Added the reported payroll forecast growth rate and corrected PEO source dates to the survey cover date or an explicit access date when publication day is unavailable.

  4. Oct 9, 2026 · analyst revision

    Added WISE automated resolution and payroll-error prevention measures to test service quality as well as usage. Verified the European leadership change and kept broader customer counts separate from payroll clients; competitive trajectories remain stable.

  5. Oct 9, 2026 · business change

    Paychex Europe appointed Jürgen Dauk as CEO and Karina Sundbæk as CFO to lead its HR, payroll and workforce software business. Europe supplies about 1% of group revenue, so the change has limited immediate effect on group earnings.

  6. Oct 9, 2026 · analyst revision

    Verified reported service and customer retention figures. Separated annual and quarterly float averages so investment yield and acquisition scope do not imply stronger customer protection; added direct evidence for WISE service results.

  7. Oct 9, 2026 · business change

    Founder Thomas Golisano left the Paychex board. He retained 10.1% beneficial ownership at the September 2026 proxy date, while John Gibson continues to run the business.

  8. Oct 9, 2026 · analyst revision

    Added the investment debate, management profile, operating KPI history and three end-market profiles. The profile now distinguishes acquisition growth, insurance volume and interest yields from competitive gains.

  9. Oct 9, 2026 · analyst revision

    Current filings and the tax judgment support stable trajectories. The payroll market classification changes from oligopoly to competitive because the filing describes fragmented national, local and online competition. The annual retention range and current operating figures do not yet show widening competitive protection.

  10. Oct 9, 2026 · business change

    Paychex raised FY2027 PEO and Insurance revenue growth guidance to 7% to 8% from 6% to 7%, and client-funds interest guidance to $200 million to $210 million from $195 million to $205 million.

  11. Oct 9, 2026 · business change

    Paychex launched WISE Hire for recruiting, available within its payroll platforms or separately; customer hiring decisions still require human control.

  12. Oct 9, 2026 · business change

    Paychex made WISE available in Microsoft 365 Copilot and Teams, extending payroll and HR actions into customer productivity tools.

  13. Oct 9, 2026 · business change

    The New York appeals court affirmed dismissal of Paychex's PEO tax-regulation challenge. Administrative proceedings continue, leaving tax exposure unresolved.

  14. Oct 9, 2026 · business change

    Paychex launched WISE, an AI engine for payroll and HR workflows; later retention and revenue will show whether automation improves its customer advantage.

  15. Oct 9, 2026 · business change

    Paychex bought Paycor for about $4.1 billion, adding mid-market HCM software and financing the deal with $4.2 billion of bonds.

Industry & peers

Peer map

0%10%20%30%40%50%60708090100Moat scoreIndustry medianPAYXWDAY

Hover a point for its values; click a peer to compare. Dashed lines: industry medians.

US payroll services

As of Oct 9, 2026
CompetitiveMedium cyclicalityUSD 12B in 2031

Payroll processing, payroll tax administration and payroll-linked HR services sold to US employers across company sizes. Standalone HR software, PEO co-employment and interest earned on client funds are outside this market; a full HCM vendor earns revenue beyond this payroll-services market.

  1. ADP
  2. Paychex
  3. Paylocity
  4. Paycom
  5. Intuit QuickBooks Payroll
2026 leaders, no comparable shares · Mordor Intelligence US payroll services
StocksMoatGross m.Op. m.
PAYX7074.4%39.2%
Industry median137074.4%19.2%
Sector median887637.3%18.0%
All stocks median3987653.1%20.0%

Moat medians cover every stock. Margin medians count only stocks with collected numbers and need at least three.

Drivers & risks

Demand drivers
  • Employers must pay workers and file taxes regularly, which supports repeat demand through the economic cycle.
  • Small employers outsource complex federal, state and local rules when maintaining an internal payroll team costs too much.
  • Cloud payroll records can support time, benefits and HR products, increasing spending with a provider that earns customer trust.
  • Distributed and multistate work increases compliance tasks and integration needs.
  • Automation can reduce payroll errors and service time, but investors need retention and paid-adoption evidence to test its value.
Risks
  • Small-business closures and weak hiring reduce customer counts and employees paid, even when payroll itself is essential.
  • ADP, specialist cloud vendors and local firms compete on price, software and service; easy onboarding can weaken switching costs.
  • Cyberattacks or tax and payroll mistakes can cause direct losses and lasting customer distrust.
  • AI errors and privacy rules can increase compliance costs and limit use of workforce data.
  • Wage inflation raises service costs. Higher borrowing rates can slow customer expansion; demand depends mainly on employer survival and hiring rather than currency or commodity prices.

Bulls & bears

Key question · as of Oct 9, 2026

Can Paychex turn Paycor and WISE into lasting client growth and better service while paying down acquisition debt, rather than relying on price increases and higher investment yields?

Arguments

3 forFaded: weakening or settled4 against

What to watch

  1. 1Payroll retention range
  2. 2Payroll clients with acquisition scope held constant
  3. 3Management Solutions revenue and product penetration
  4. 4ASO and PEO worksite employees
  5. 5PEO insurance costs and reserve development
  6. 6Paycor integration costs and debt principal
  7. 7Average client funds and earned yield
  8. 8WISE adoption and service resolution

Next check: Read the FY2027 second-quarter filing after the November 30, 2026 period end; check Management Solutions growth, integration costs, cash flow and insurance reserves. Recheck annual retention at FY2027 year-end.

Sources: company filings and dated sources collected for Find My Moat; market cap as of Nov 9, 2026. Not investment advice.

Cite or reuse this data

Free to reuse, commercially too, with a credit link. See the data license.

Moat Score 70/100 by <a href="https://www.findmymoat.com/stocks/XNAS:PAYX">Find My Moat</a> (as of September 2026)

Curation & Accuracy

This directory blends AI‑assisted discovery with human curation. Entries are reviewed, edited, and organized with the goal of expanding coverage and sharpening quality over time. Your feedback helps steer improvements (because no single human can capture everything all at once).

Details change. Pricing, features, and availability may be incomplete or out of date. Treat listings as a starting point and verify on the provider’s site before making decisions. If you spot an error or a gap, send a quick note and I’ll adjust.