Magic Formula Investing Alternatives & Competitors

Checking

 

Replacement verdicts

Magic Formula Investing logo logo placeholder

Alternatives to Magic Formula Investing

Curated replacements grouped by fit, tradeoffs, pricing flexibility, and platform access. Use this list to decide which Magic Formula Investing competitor is worth testing first.

Looking for a Magic Formula Investing replacement? We've profiled 6 alternatives by workflow fit, pricing flexibility, caveats, and platform access. Whether you need a free option to trial, mobile-ready workflows, or API integrations, this list helps you choose what to test first.

Disclosure: outbound links may include affiliate or sponsor links

Which Alternative Should You Use?

Portfolio123 logo logo placeholder

Portfolio123

Closest replacement

Best for: Rules-based investors looking for point-in-time stock and ETF simulations.

  • Portfolio123 best matches the base workflow on factor screening, quant research, and fundamental research.
  • Portfolio123 also has a free plan, so you can try it without paying. Free-plan limits: Signup required. Free Manage module is separate from paid Research, API, and DataMiner access.

Watch for: Advanced research is paid: Free Manage covers portfolio tracking. Time-limited access covers screener and backtesting use before a paid Research plan, while API and DataMiner require separate paid access.

Validea logo logo placeholder

Validea

Best workflow fit

Best for: Investors who want stock and ETF portfolios, screens, and reports based on published guru and academic factor models.

  • Validea best matches the base workflow on stock screening, factor screening, and quant research.
  • Validea also has a free plan, so you can try it without paying. Free-plan limits: Public pages include a weekly email newsletter and limited screen and portfolio results.

Watch for: Model returns are not live account returns: Validea states model returns do not reflect actual trading and may include backtested and live model performance.

Uncle Stock logo

Uncle Stock

Best audience fit

Best for: Value and long-term investors screening global companies by financial statements, ratios, scores, and valuation models.

  • Uncle Stock best matches the base workflow on stock screening, fundamental research, and screening and idea generation.
  • Uncle Stock also has a free plan, so you can try it without paying. Free-plan limits: Signup required. Subscription page lists Bronze at $20/month or $130/year, Silver at $35/month or $210/year, and Gold at $60/month or $350/year.

Watch for: API is Gold-gated and capped: The JSON Search API requires Gold and is capped at 10 calls per minute and 300 calls per month unless the vendor raises the limit.

FactorsToday logo

FactorsToday

Strong runner-up

Best for: Quantitative researchers studying factor returns, stock loadings, correlations, and attribution.

  • FactorsToday best matches the base workflow on stock screening, quant research, and fundamental research.
  • FactorsToday also has a free plan, so you can try it without paying. Free-plan limits: Public dashboards and API documentation can be opened without signing in.

Watch for: Pricing not published: The site exposes public tools and a no-key API but publishes no long-term access or commercial pricing policy.

Detailed Alternatives

I want to

Our ranked order by workflow overlap and quality.

1
Portfolio123 logo logo placeholder
Closest replacement

Portfolio123

Analyst pickTested by us

Bottom line: Rules-based investors looking for point-in-time stock and ETF simulations.

Keep

  • Screeners
  • Stock Ideas

Gain

  • Data Visualizations
  • Quant
  • Scores
  • Valuation Models

Lose

No missing capabilities listed.

Watch out

  • Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on stock screening, stock research, and dividend research.
  • Free-plan limits: Signup required. Free Manage module is separate from paid Research, API, and DataMiner access. General registration offers 30 days of screener and backtesting access without a payment card.
  • Advanced research is paid: Free Manage covers portfolio tracking. Time-limited access covers screener and backtesting use before a paid Research plan, while API and DataMiner require separate paid access.
Cost
Free with signup

$25/moto go paid, billed yearly

Magic Formula Investing has no paid plan

2
Validea logo logo placeholder
Best workflow fit

Bottom line: Investors who want stock and ETF portfolios, screens, and reports based on published guru and academic factor models.

Keep

  • Screeners
  • Stock Ideas

Gain

  • ETF Screeners
  • Quant
  • Backtesting
  • Scores

Lose

No missing capabilities listed.

Watch out

  • Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on stock research, API and market data, and dividend research.
  • Free-plan limits: Public pages include a weekly email newsletter and limited screen and portfolio results. The site limits monthly page views before requiring a trial or paid subscription. New subscriptions and trials are paused; the FAQ still advertises older seven-day trials.
  • Model returns are not live account returns: Validea states model returns do not reflect actual trading and may include backtested and live model performance.
Cost
Free, no signup

$22.50/moto go paid, billed yearly

Magic Formula Investing has no paid plan

3
FactorsToday logo
Partial replacement

Bottom line: Quantitative researchers studying factor returns, stock loadings, correlations, and attribution.

Keep

  • Screeners

Gain

  • Quant
  • Data Visualizations
  • Stock Comparison
  • Factor Exposure

Lose

  • Stock Ideas

Watch out

  • Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on factor screening, stock research, and news and alerts.
  • Free-plan limits: Public dashboards and API documentation can be opened without signing in. The API does not currently require a key and is limited to ten requests per second per IP address. No paid pricing table or durable free-access commitment is published.
  • Pricing not published: The site exposes public tools and a no-key API but publishes no long-term access or commercial pricing policy.
Cost
Free, no signup

Free onlyno paid tier

4
Uncle Stock logo
Uncle StockBest audience fit
4
Uncle Stock logo
Best audience fit

Uncle Stock

Analyst pickTested by us

Bottom line: Value and long-term investors screening global companies by financial statements, ratios, scores, and valuation models.

Keep

  • Screeners

Gain

  • Backtesting
  • Data Visualizations
  • Financials
  • Valuation Models

Lose

  • Stock Ideas

Watch out

  • Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on factor screening, quant research, and stock research.
  • Free-plan limits: Signup required. Subscription page lists Bronze at $20/month or $130/year, Silver at $35/month or $210/year, and Gold at $60/month or $350/year. Gold adds CSV export and a higher MCP search quota. The current subscription page and MCP documentation list 75 Gold stock searches per day.
  • API is Gold-gated and capped: The JSON Search API requires Gold and is capped at 10 calls per minute and 300 calls per month unless the vendor raises the limit.
Cost
Free with signup

$10.83/moto go paid, billed yearly

Magic Formula Investing has no paid plan

5
Stockopedia logo
StockopediaPartial replacement
5
Stockopedia logo
Partial replacement

Stockopedia

Analyst pickTested by us

Bottom line: DIY stock investors looking for systematic Quality, Value, and Momentum ranks with broad regional coverage.

Keep

  • Screeners
  • Stock Ideas

Gain

  • Financials
  • Scores
  • Checklist
  • Data Visualizations

Lose

  • Free tier

Watch out

  • Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on quant research, stock research, and backtesting and quant research.
  • Free-plan limits: Signup required. Credit card required. Trial-only access.
  • Subscription-only product: Stockopedia is paid after the free trial and pricing depends on regional market access.
Cost
Free trial only

Subscription

6
QuantConnect logo
QuantConnectBetter as a complement
6
QuantConnect logo
Better as a complement

Bottom line: Quants and systematic traders looking for an end-to-end research, backtesting, cloud deployment, and live-trading workflow on LEAN.

Keep

No shared workflows named.

Gain

  • Quant
  • Backtesting
  • Paper Trading
  • Auto-Trading & Bots

Lose

  • Screeners
  • Stock Ideas

Watch out

  • Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on stock screening, factor screening, and stock research.
  • Free-plan limits: Signup required. Free tier includes one free backtest node and one free research node according to QuantConnect tier documentation. Paid pricing depends on the selected organization tier, seats, compute nodes, data, and support.
  • Underlying data export is restricted: You may export your own code and normal strategy summary results, such as performance and order history. Platform datasets and outputs designed to reproduce them cannot be extracted through logs, files, APIs, MCP or other channels.
Cost
Free with signup

Free • Contact for pricing

What This Shortlist Tells You

Portfolio123 is the closest drop-in replacement with overlapping coverage in Screeners and Stock Ideas while adding Data Visualizations and Quant coverage and Build multifactor ranking systems, stock and ETF screens, and rules-based strategies with point-in-time data. and Run backtests for US, Canadian, and European equities with custom universes, buy and sell rules, position sizing, hedging, slippage, and commissions. features (workflow overlap ~100%).

Free tiers remain available through Portfolio123, Validea, FactorsToday, Uncle Stock, and QuantConnect for side-by-side testing.

Need mobile access? Stockopedia bring phone-ready workflows that Magic Formula Investing lacks.

Round out your stack with new coverage areas like Data Visualizations, Quant, Scores, and Valuation Models.

Coverage Snapshot

Where alternatives already align

Most shared categories across the top matches.

New angles introduced

Categories the alternatives add beyond Magic Formula Investing.

Access & Pricing

Free to start

5/6

5 of 6 start free, same as Magic Formula Investing.

Paid plans from

$10.83/mo

Uncle Stock is the cheapest listed monthly upgrade. No comparable monthly price is listed for Magic Formula Investing.

Mobile app

1 of 6

1 add a mobile app that Magic Formula Investing lacks.

API access

4 of 6

4 expose an API or data feed, usually on a paid plan.

Hands-on tested

3 of 6

3 tested hands-on. 3 are analyst picks.

Coverage overlap

67%

Average share of Magic Formula Investing categories each alternative covers.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best alternatives to Magic Formula Investing?

Portfolio123, Validea, and FactorsToday share the most workflows with Magic Formula Investing, in that order. Start with the one whose Keep list matches what you use daily.

Which alternatives keep a free tier?

Portfolio123, Validea, FactorsToday, Uncle Stock, and QuantConnect start free, so you can test them before paying. Check each card for signup and usage limits on the free plan.

Which workflows do the top Magic Formula Investing alternatives cover?

Between them the top matches cover Screeners and Stock Ideas. Magic Formula Investing workflows in those areas move over as they are. The Lose column on each card names what does not.

Feedback

Missing an alternative, or is a listing out of date? Tell me and I will look.

Curation & Accuracy

This directory blends AI‑assisted discovery with human curation. Entries are reviewed, edited, and organized with the goal of expanding coverage and sharpening quality over time. Your feedback helps steer improvements (because no single human can capture everything all at once).

Details change. Pricing, features, and availability may be incomplete or out of date. Treat listings as a starting point and verify on the provider’s site before making decisions. If you spot an error or a gap, send a quick note and I’ll adjust.