VOL. XCIV, NO. 247

Vanguard Brokerage Alternatives & Competitors

Checking

Replacement verdicts

Alternatives to Vanguard Brokerage

Curated replacements grouped by fit, tradeoffs, pricing flexibility, and platform access. Use this list to decide which Vanguard Brokerage competitor is worth testing first.

Looking for a Vanguard Brokerage replacement? We've profiled 20 alternatives by workflow fit, pricing flexibility, caveats, and platform access. Whether you need a free option to trial, mobile-ready workflows, or API integrations, this list helps you choose what to test first.

Visit Vanguard Brokerage Free alternatives Tool details

Disclosure: outbound links may include affiliate or sponsor links

Which Alternative Should You Use?

Fidelity (Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC)

Closest replacement

Best for: U.S. investors looking for $0 online stock and most ETF trades, research, tax documents, and several account types.

Fidelity (Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC) best matches the base workflow on brokerage trading, portfolio tracking, and portfolio analytics.
Fidelity (Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC) shares Free pricing with the base tool.

Watch for: Not all trades are free: Options contracts, secondary bonds/CDs, crypto transactions, professional options fees, regulatory fees, and certain ETF purchase service fees can apply.

Open Fidelity account

Details Compare

Koyfin

Best audience fit

Best for: Investors who want dashboards, charts, screeners, portfolios, news, and alerts in a web and mobile workspace.

Koyfin best matches the base workflow on portfolio tracking, portfolio analytics, and fundamental research.
Koyfin adds a free starting point that the base tool does not show. Free access caveat: signup required and Free plan includes limited watchlists, screens, dashboards, alerts, portfolios, financials, and estimates history..

Watch for: No public API: Koyfin does not provide user-facing data access through an API.

View Koyfin pricing

Details Compare

Interactive Brokers (IBKR)

Quality-checked pick

Best for: Active investors who need global multi-asset access, advanced orders, APIs, and volume-based commissions.

Interactive Brokers (IBKR) best matches the base workflow on brokerage trading, portfolio tracking, and portfolio analytics.
Interactive Brokers (IBKR) shares Free pricing with the base tool.

Watch for: Commission and market-data details vary by market: The record contains separate stock, ETF, options, futures, crypto, and market-data pricing notes by region and product.

Open IBKR account

Details Compare

E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Strong runner-up

Best for: U.S. self-directed investors who need several account types, research, retirement administration, and multiple trading platforms.

E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley best matches the base workflow on brokerage trading, portfolio tracking, and options and trading workflows.
E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley shares Free pricing with the base tool.

Watch for: Low default cash rate: The standard Bank Deposit Program pays 0.01% below $500,000 under the current tier schedule.

Open E*TRADE

Details Compare

Detailed Alternatives

I want to

Pay lessFill a gapUpgrade overall

Our ranked order by workflow overlap and quality.

Closest replacement

Fidelity (Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC)

Bottom line: U.S. investors looking for $0 online stock and most ETF trades, research, tax documents, and several account types.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist

Gain

Advanced Order Types
Smart/Direct Routing
Order Book / Level II
News

Lose

Downloadable Tax Reports
Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on advisor and client reporting.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, Brokerage use requires an approved Fidelity account, and Options, international trading, margin, crypto, and active-trader workflows have separate rules or approvals.
Not all trades are free: Options contracts, secondary bonds/CDs, crypto transactions, professional options fees, regulatory fees, and certain ETF purchase service fees can apply.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Fidelity (Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC)Transaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Drop-in replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open Fidelity account Compare

Full review and details

Quality-checked pick

Interactive Brokers (IBKR)

Analyst pickTested by us

Bottom line: Active investors who need global multi-asset access, advanced orders, APIs, and volume-based commissions.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist

Gain

Advanced Order Types
Smart/Direct Routing
Paper Trading
Options

Lose

Downloadable Tax Reports
Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on fundamental research and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, Brokerage account has no recurring platform fee in the profile, but trading commissions and add-on fees vary by product, and Real-time market data and Level II data generally require subscriptions.
Commission and market-data details vary by market: The record contains separate stock, ETF, options, futures, crypto, and market-data pricing notes by region and product.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Interactive Brokers (IBKR)Transaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Drop-in replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open IBKR account Compare

Full review and details

Partial replacement

E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Bottom line: U.S. self-directed investors who need several account types, research, retirement administration, and multiple trading platforms.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Advanced Order Types
Options
$0 online U.S. exchange-listed stock and ETF commissions; options cost $0.65 or $0.50 per contract by activity tier.
Eligible listed Reg-NMS fractions start at $5 and support quantities to three decimal places during the rollout.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, Brokerage features require an approved account and cleared funding, and Options, margin, futures, crypto and specialized registrations require separate eligibility.
Low default cash rate: The standard Bank Deposit Program pays 0.01% below $500,000 under the current tier schedule.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
E*TRADE from Morgan StanleyTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Partial replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open E*TRADE Compare

Full review and details

Public.comPartial replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Partial replacement

Public.com

Bottom line: Eligible U.S. investors looking for stocks, ETFs, bonds, and options in one self-directed interface.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Options
Regular-hours U.S.-listed stock and ETF commission is $0; extended-hours and OTC trading costs $2.99 without Premium.
Investment Plans cost $0.49 to $1.99 per recurring stock and ETF purchase unless Premium waives the charge.
Primary brokerage free cash earns 0%; the separate HYCA currently states a variable 3.30% APY.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, An approved eligible U.S. brokerage account is required, and Regular-hours U.S.-listed equity trades are free, but extended-hours, OTC, plan, transfer, and regulatory fees can apply.
U.S.-only onboarding: Opening requires a U.S. residential address, valid SSN, and supported citizenship, residency, or visa status.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Public.comTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Partial replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open Public Compare

Full review and details

Scalable CapitalPartial replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Partial replacement

Scalable Capital

Bottom line: European investors comparing low-cost broker plans for stocks, ETFs, funds, bonds, crypto ETPs, derivatives, and savings plans.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Wealth Management
FREE costs €0 per month and PRIME+ costs €4.99. Through August 31, 2026, eligible EIX and gettex trades cost €0.99 on FREE and €0 on PRIME+ above €250. From September 1, gettex trades will cost €1.99 on both plans. Xetra currently costs €1.99. Savings plan executions are free.
Earn variable 2.5% annual interest on uninvested cash per current EU pricing pages; PRIME+ can distribute cash across up to five banks for up to 5 x €100,000 statutory deposit protection, otherwise cash may be held at banks or in money-market funds.
The broker lists more than 1.8 million derivatives from seven issuers. PRIME+ includes eligible trades above €250 through supported venues until the stated venue rules change.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, Brokerage use requires an eligible Scalable account, and FREE and PRIME+ plans have different order-fee rules.
Region-limited broker: Coverage is focused on supported European countries and local regulatory/product availability.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Scalable CapitalTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Partial replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Compare Scalable costs Compare

Full review and details

DEGIROPartial replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Partial replacement

DEGIRO

Analyst pickTested by us

Bottom line: European investors looking for low-cost self-directed access to stocks, ETFs, bonds, funds, options, and futures.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Advanced Order Types
Smart/Direct Routing
News
Calendar

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, Trading requires an approved brokerage account, and Transaction, handling, currency-conversion, connectivity, and market-data fees can apply.
Execution-only broker: DEGIRO does not provide investment advice or portfolio management.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
DEGIROTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Partial replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open DEGIRO account Compare

Full review and details

Rakuten SecuritiesPartial replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Partial replacement

Rakuten Securities

Bottom line: Japan residents who need Japanese and U.S. securities, funds, bonds, and derivatives in one account.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Options
Zero Course domestic cash-equity brokerage is ¥0 when its SOR/R-Cross conditions are accepted.
U.S. stock and ETF commissions are 0.495%, with a $0 minimum and $22 maximum before other charges.
Kabumini trades eligible Japanese shares below the standard lot from one share.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, Applicants must be Japan residents and pass identity, tax and account screening, and Zero Course domestic pricing has SOR/R-Cross and electronic-service conditions.
Japan residents only: The modeled account is not open as a general overseas route, and non-resident customers face restrictions.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Rakuten SecuritiesTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Partial replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open Rakuten Securities Compare

Full review and details

SBI SecuritiesPartial replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Partial replacement

SBI Securities

Bottom line: Japan residents who need domestic shares, U.S. securities, funds, bonds, and derivatives in one account.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Options
Zero Revolution lists ¥0 brokerage for eligible domestic cash, margin and S-share orders under its conditions.
U.S. security commissions are 0.495%, with a $0 minimum and $22 maximum before other charges.
S-shares provide eligible Japanese securities below the standard lot from one share.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, Applicants must be Japan residents and pass identity, My Number and bank-account checks, and Domestic zero brokerage requires electronic-delivery and course conditions.
Japan residents only: SBI limits opening to domestic residents and states it does not hold overseas securities-business licenses.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
SBI SecuritiesTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Partial replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open SBI Securities Compare

Full review and details

SMARTBROKER+Drop-in replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Drop-in replacement

SMARTBROKER+

Bottom line: Eligible European residents who want a depot without custody fees and with low-cost gettex execution.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

gettex orders in eligible securities cost €0 from €500 or €1 below €500 under the published premium-partner conditions.
Savings-plan execution is €0 for eligible stocks, ETFs, ETCs, funds and crypto ETPs.
Residents of Germany, France, Italy, Spain, Austria, the Netherlands, Belgium, Ireland and Luxembourg can apply, subject to approval.
The separate Baader Bank interest account pays a variable 2.00% to €100,000 and 1.75% from €100,000 to €1 million as reviewed.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, An approved depot and app-based identity verification are required, and €0 execution is conditional on gettex, premium-partner eligibility and €500 order value.
Nine-country eligibility: New accounts are limited to residents of nine named European countries and exclude people subject to U.S. tax.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
SMARTBROKER+Transaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Drop-in replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open SMARTBROKER+Compare

Full review and details

Hargreaves LansdownDrop-in replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Drop-in replacement

Hargreaves Lansdown

Bottom line: UK investors looking for broad funds, shares, ETFs, bonds, ISA, LISA, junior, trust, and pension accounts in one established platform.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Advanced Order Types
Funds have a tiered annual account charge starting at 0.35%; listed assets are generally 0.35% capped at £150 per account annually.
One-off online fund trades cost £1.95; listed-security trades cost £6.95 or £3.95 after 20+ prior-month trades.
Overseas share FX is tiered at 0.99%, 0.50%, and 0.20% by trade value.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on fundamental research, charting and technical analysis, and API and market data.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, Brokerage use requires an approved account and applicable UK residence/wrapper eligibility, and Platform, dealing, FX, tax, levy, and product charges can apply.
Percentage platform charge: Funds and most listed assets carry 0.35% entry-tier account charges, with different tiers, caps, and junior-account exceptions.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Hargreaves LansdownTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Drop-in replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open an HL account Compare

Full review and details

Charles SchwabPartial replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Partial replacement

Charles Schwab

Bottom line: U.S. investors who want brokerage, trading platforms, research, tax workflows, and several asset classes in one account.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist

Gain

Options
Paper Trading
Advanced Order Types
Smart/Direct Routing

Lose

Downloadable Tax Reports
Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on fundamental research, charting and technical analysis, and filings and transcript research.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, Brokerage use requires an approved Schwab account, and Options, futures, forex, margin, and API workflows require separate approval or authorization.
Advanced products need approval: Options, futures, forex, margin, and crypto access have separate approval, risk, and eligibility requirements.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Charles SchwabTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Partial replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open Schwab account Compare

Full review and details

Merrill EdgePartial replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Partial replacement

Merrill Edge

Bottom line: U.S. Bank of America customers valuing linked banking, immediate eligible transfers, and relationship-level visibility.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Advanced Order Types
Options
$0 online stock and ETF commissions and $0 option base commission plus $0.65 per contract.
Linked eligible Bank of America transfers can be real time; external bank, wire, check, and account-transfer funding are supported.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, Brokerage use requires an approved Merrill account, and Options, margin, trust, estate and business accounts have additional rules.
Low standard cash rate: The standard bank sweep pays 0.01% below $1 million under the current rate sheet.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Merrill EdgeTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Partial replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open Merrill Edge Compare

Full review and details

FirstradePartial replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Partial replacement

Firstrade

Bottom line: U.S. and supported international investors seeking $0 online stock, ETF, mutual-fund, and options commissions.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Options
Stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, and listed options have $0 stated online commissions and $0 standard options contract fees.
International brokerage is available only for the current official matrix of 27 countries and regions.
Fractional trading covers selected equities and ETFs, but fractions cannot transfer and carry voting and liquidity limitations.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, An approved domestic or supported international brokerage account is required, and Regulatory, short-borrow, fixed-income, fund, broker-assisted, and transfer costs can apply.
Restricted international matrix: International onboarding is limited to 27 named countries and regions and cannot be generalized globally.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
FirstradeTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Partial replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open Firstrade Compare

Full review and details

National Bank Direct BrokeragePartial replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Partial replacement

National Bank Direct Brokerage

Bottom line: Canadian residents seeking $0 online Canadian and U.S. stock and ETF commissions.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Options
Online Canadian and U.S. stocks and ETFs carry $0 stated commission.
A $100 annual administration fee is waived under published asset, age, InvestCube or offer conditions.
Uninvested brokerage credit balances currently pay 0% in the live pricing table.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, An approved Canadian-resident brokerage account is required, and The $100 annual administration fee requires a published waiver condition to avoid.
Canada-only online opening: The online application requires Canadian residence and age 18 or older.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
National Bank Direct BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Partial replacement

Pricing checked 2026-09-02 via pricing.

Open NBDB Compare

Full review and details

Qtrade Direct InvestingPartial replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Partial replacement

Qtrade Direct Investing

Bottom line: Canadian residents seeking $0 online equity, ETF and mutual-fund commissions.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Options
Online equities, ETFs and mutual funds carry $0 stated commission.
Online options cost $0 plus $0.75 per contract, with separate assignment and exercise fees.
Published cash-credit rates are 0% through C$2 million and 0.10% above in CAD, while USD remains 0%.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, An approved Canadian brokerage account is required, and Transaction, product, service, FX and transfer fees can apply despite $0 equity and ETF commissions.
Canada-only opening: New applicants must be Canadian residents and meet provincial or territorial age requirements.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Qtrade Direct InvestingTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Partial replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open Qtrade Compare

Full review and details

CIBC Investor's EdgePartial replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Partial replacement

CIBC Investor's Edge

Bottom line: Canadian residents who want self-directed brokerage linked to CIBC banking.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Options
Standard online stock and ETF trades cost $6.95, or $4.95 under Active Trader pricing.
Over 180 selected ETFs can trade commission-free when the live list and holding rules are met.
All ordinary CAD and USD brokerage credit balances currently pay 0%.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, An approved Canadian-resident brokerage account is required, and Standard equity and options trades are paid.
Canada-only opening: Individual opening is limited to eligible Canadian residents.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
CIBC Investor's EdgeTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Partial replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open CIBC Edge Compare

Full review and details

Monex SecuritiesPartial replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Partial replacement

Monex Securities

Bottom line: Japan residents who need Japanese and U.S. securities in one self-directed account.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Options
Domestic per-order commissions start at ¥55 and top out at ¥1,070 under the published online tiers.
U.S. security commissions are 0.495%, with a $0 minimum and $22 maximum before other charges.
One Share buys eligible Japanese securities below the standard lot from one share.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, Applicants must be Japan residents and pass identity, My Number and linked-bank checks, and Domestic, U.S., odd-lot, currency and derivative transactions use different schedules.
Japan residents only: The ordinary account is limited to Japan residents and is restricted when a customer becomes non-resident.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Monex SecuritiesTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Partial replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open Monex Securities Compare

Full review and details

AJ BellDrop-in replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Drop-in replacement

AJ Bell

Bottom line: UK investors looking for taxable, ISA, LISA, junior, trust, company, and pension accounts with one provider.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Advanced Order Types
Share custody is 0.25% with monthly caps from £2.50 to £10 depending on the account wrapper.
Fund custody is generally 0.25% on the first £250,000, 0.10% on the next £250,000, then zero.
Online dealing costs £5 for listed securities or £1.50 for funds; frequent share dealing can fall to £3.50.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, Brokerage access requires an approved eligible UK account, and Shares, funds, FX, taxes, levies, and investment products can each add charges.
UK tax residence required: New online accounts require UK tax residence. U.S. and Canadian citizens or tax residents are excluded.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
AJ BellTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Drop-in replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open AJ Bell Compare

Full review and details

KoyfinBest audience fitFree • From $468/yrFree with signup

Best audience fit

Koyfin

Analyst pickTested by us

Bottom line: Investors who want dashboards, charts, screeners, portfolios, news, and alerts in a web and mobile workspace.

Keep

Portfolio
Watchlist

Gain

Screeners
ETF Screeners
Data Visualizations
Custom Dashboards

Lose

Brokerage
Downloadable Tax Reports
Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on brokerage trading.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, Free plan includes limited watchlists, screens, dashboards, alerts, portfolios, financials, and estimates history, and New accounts receive a seven-day trial and then downgrade to Free without a charge.
No public API: Koyfin does not provide user-facing data access through an API.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
KoyfinFree • From $468/yr
Free tier: Free with signup
Replacement: Partial replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

View Koyfin pricing Compare

Full review and details

WealthsimpleDrop-in replacementTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdictionPaid only

Drop-in replacement

Wealthsimple

Bottom line: Canadian residents seeking $0 online commissions for listed Canadian and U.S. stocks and ETFs.

Keep

Brokerage
Portfolio
Watchlist
Downloadable Tax Reports

Gain

Options
Canadian and U.S. listed stock and ETF trades have $0 stated online commission.
Fractional stock and ETF market orders start at $1.
Core clients pay $10 CAD plus tax monthly for USD accounts after a 30-day trial; Premium and Generation include them.

Lose

Online stocks and ETFs trade at $0 commission; standard options cost $1 per contract.
Vanguard ETF dollar-based orders start at $1, while non-Vanguard securities are not generalized as fraction-eligible.
Vanguard Cash Deposit pays 1.75% variable APY as of August 20, 2026 and is eligible for program-bank FDIC coverage.
VMFXX is the alternative settlement fund and is a money-market security with SIPC eligibility, not an FDIC deposit.

Watch out

Avoid as a full replacement if you rely on portfolio analytics, fundamental research, and charting and technical analysis.
Free-plan limits: Signup required, An approved Canadian-resident brokerage account is required, and Currency conversion, index-option, exercise, instant-withdrawal and product costs can apply.
Canada-only eligibility: Individual applicants must reside in Canada and meet provincial or territorial age-of-majority requirements.

Price: Vanguard BrokerageTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
WealthsimpleTransaction-priced · Fees vary by offer and jurisdiction
Free tier: Paid only
Replacement: Drop-in replacement

Pricing checked 2026-08-23 via pricing.

Open Wealthsimple Compare

Full review and details

What This Shortlist Tells You

Fidelity (Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC) is the closest drop-in replacement with overlapping coverage in Brokerage, Portfolio, and Watchlist while adding Advanced Order Types and Smart/Direct Routing coverage and Online U.S. stock and most ETF trades have no Fidelity commission. Online options cost $0.65 per contract. and Purchases of a limited group of ETFs incur a $100 Fidelity service fee. features (workflow overlap ~75%).

Budget-conscious? Try Koyfin to get started without a paid plan.

Round out your stack with new coverage areas like Advanced Order Types, Smart/Direct Routing, Order Book / Level II, and News.

Coverage Snapshot

Where alternatives already align

Most shared categories across the top matches.

Portfolio×20Watchlist×20Brokerage×19Downloadable Tax Reports×16

New angles introduced

Categories the alternatives add beyond Vanguard Brokerage.

Options+14Advanced Order Types+8News+5Smart/Direct Routing+4Calendar+3Order Book / Level II+3Screeners+3Alerts+2

Access & Pricing

Free options

1/20

1 picks introduce a free tier you can start with.

Mobile ready

20/20

20 matches support mobile alongside Vanguard Brokerage.

API availability

3/20

3 of the shortlisted tools expose API endpoints for automation-heavy workflows.

Quality checks

3 starred / 3 tested

3 tools are flagged as analyst picks; 3 have been hands-on tested.

Avg. coverage overlap

94%

Average percentage of categories shared with the base tool.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best alternatives to Vanguard Brokerage?

Vanguard Brokerage users most often consider Fidelity (Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC), Interactive Brokers (IBKR), and E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley as their go-to alternatives.

Which alternatives keep a free tier?

Koyfin offer a free plan or trial option, making them easy to test before committing to a paid subscription.

Which workflows do the top Vanguard Brokerage alternatives cover?

Expect deep coverage across Brokerage, Downloadable Tax Reports, Portfolio, and Watchlist, so you can port most Vanguard Brokerage workflows without much friction.

Keep Exploring

Wide Moat StocksBrowse the current moat score ranking and company-level moat notes.

Short InterestDaily tracker for heavily shorted stocks and short squeeze candidates.

Stock RankingsBacktested ranking systems for quality, value, momentum, and more.

Live AnalyticsSee what users are clicking, searching, and voting for across the site.

Research ToolsFind screeners, data platforms, portfolio trackers, and research tools.

Feedback

Missing an alternative, or is a listing out of date? Tell me and I will look.

Curation & Accuracy

This directory blends AI‑assisted discovery with human curation. Entries are reviewed, edited, and organized with the goal of expanding coverage and sharpening quality over time. Your feedback helps steer improvements (because no single human can capture everything all at once).

Details change. Pricing, features, and availability may be incomplete or out of date. Treat listings as a starting point and verify on the provider’s site before making decisions. If you spot an error or a gap, send a quick note and I’ll adjust.

★Vanguard Brokerage Alternatives & Competitors★

Alternatives to Vanguard Brokerage

Which Alternative Should You Use?

Fidelity (Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC)

Koyfin

Interactive Brokers (IBKR)

E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Detailed Alternatives

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Keep

Gain

Lose

Watch out

Vanguard Brokerage Alternatives & Competitors