VOL. XCIV, NO. 247
BOOK BREAKDOWN
NO ADVICE
Wednesday, January 14, 2026
Beginner · 1994
Beating the Street
by Peter Lynch, John Rothchild · Partly Dated
Lynch shows how he actually found and vetted real investments - then turns it into a repeatable DIY process for stock picking and mutual fund selection.
Level
Beginner
Strategies
5 types
Frameworks
5 frameworks
Rating
Target Audience
Ideal Reader
- DIY investors who want examples of real decisions, not just theory
- People who liked One Up On Wall Street and want deeper case studies
- Investors who want a practical mutual-fund selection framework (not just index vs active)
- Anyone building a personal stock-picking checklist and decision journal
May Not Suit
- Pure index-only investors who do not want any stock/fund selection discussion
- Readers who want a valuation textbook (DCF/accounting deep dive)
- Short-term traders looking for setups and timing rules
Investor Fit
| Strategy | Growth Investing · Value Investing · Portfolio Management · Behavioral Finance · Special Situations |
| Time Horizon | Medium-term (1–5 years) · Long-term (5+ years) |
| Asset Focus | Equities · Mutual Funds |
| Math Level | Basic Arithmetic |
| Prerequisites | Understands basic investing terms (stock, fund, dividend) · Can read simple financial statement line items (sales, earnings, debt) · Comfortable with basic ratios (P/E, growth rate, leverage) |
Key Learnings
- 1The edge for individuals is not speed; it is patience + doing your own homework
- 2Stock picking is learnable: you do not need a Quotron - just a repeatable process
- 3Strong research combines real-world observation (legwork) with simple financial checks
- 4A few big winners can dominate results; your job is to avoid blow-ups and stay invested in the winners
- 5Bad news can create mispricings, but only if you can separate temporary issues from permanent impairment
- 6Fund performance-chasing is a trap; you need a fund strategy, not a fund-of-the-month habit
- 7Knowing what you own (thesis clarity) is what prevents panic decisions
- 8Complex or inconvenient securities can be mispriced because many investors cannot or will not do the work
Frameworks (5)
Formulas (5)
Case Studies (6)
St. Agnes School stock portfolio (investment club example)
Takeaway
Process + homework can beat credential worship; amateurs lose when they stop doing the work.
Supercuts
Takeaway
Even good stories can have execution and valuation traps; thesis tracking matters.
Master Limited Partnerships (MLPs)
Takeaway
Complex structures can be mispriced, but taxes/structure/liquidity must be understood before you size up.
CMS Energy (distress / complex assets)
Takeaway
Distress can create opportunity, but leverage and survivability dominate the outcome.
Government/forced asset sales (Uncle Sam's garage sale)
Takeaway
Forced sellers can create bargains; edge comes from doing the work others avoid.
The Colonial (local/overlooked opportunity example)
Takeaway
You can find ideas close to home, but you still need fundamentals and a clear thesis.
Notable Quotes
“Never invest in any idea you can't illustrate with a crayon.”
Mental Models
- —Legwork -> thesis -> numbers -> buy/sell rules (process over prediction)
- —Bad-news investing: the price often moves before the facts settle
- —Winner/loser asymmetry: one or two big winners matter; do not cut them reflexively
- —Portfolio survivability: diversify enough so one mistake cannot wreck you
- —Fund selection as a behavior problem: your biggest enemy is switching at the wrong time
Key Terms
No glossary terms documented for this book.
Limitations & Caveats
Keep in mind
- •Examples are era-specific; principles generalize, but details (fund landscape, market structure) changed
- •Not a full valuation/modeling book; you still need a valuation toolkit for precision
- •Some special situations (e.g., MLPs) have tax/structure complexity that beginners can mishandle
Reading Guide
Priority Reading
- The Miracle of St. Agnes
- The Weekend Worrier
- Managing Magellan (early/middle/later years)
- Art, Science, and Legwork
- Prospecting in Bad News
- Master Limited Partnerships
- Nukes in Distress (CMS Energy)
Optional Sections
- —Some era-specific company anecdotes if you only want the process
Ratings
Concept Tags
Ready to apply these frameworks?
See concepts from this book applied to real companies with moat scores and segment analysis.
View the moat stocks listLooking for more reading?
Explore our curated collection of investing books organized by level and strategy.
Browse more booksCuration & Accuracy
This directory blends AI‑assisted discovery with human curation. Entries are reviewed, edited, and organized with the goal of expanding coverage and sharpening quality over time. Your feedback helps steer improvements (because no single human can capture everything all at once).
Details change. Pricing, features, and availability may be incomplete or out of date. Treat listings as a starting point and verify on the provider’s site before making decisions. If you spot an error or a gap, send a quick note and I’ll adjust.