VOL. XCIV, NO. 247
BOOK BREAKDOWN
NO ADVICE
Intermediate · 1852
Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds
by Charles Mackay · Partly Dated
A historical casebook of social contagion - how crowds inflate manias and delusions (including famous financial bubbles) and why sane individuals still get swept up.
Level
Intermediate
Strategies
2 types
Frameworks
3 frameworks
Rating
Target Audience
Ideal Reader
- Investors who want better bubble/mania pattern recognition (behavior over spreadsheets)
- Anyone prone to FOMO who needs historical perspective to stay disciplined
- Macro / sentiment-focused investors as a cement to quantitative tools
- People building a personal 'anti-mania' checklist and decision rules
May Not Suit
- Readers expecting modern portfolio construction, indexing guidance, or fund selection
- Anyone looking for valuation models, accounting analysis, or stock screens
- People who strongly dislike 19th-century prose and anecdotal storytelling
Investor Fit
| Strategy | Behavioral Finance · Macro/Global |
| Time Horizon | Long-term (5+ years) |
| Asset Focus | Macro/FX · Multi-Asset · Equities |
| Math Level | No Math Required |
| Prerequisites | Comfortable reading older prose (or using it as a skim/reference) · Basic understanding of what bubbles/speculation look like in markets |
Key Learnings
- 1Crowd behavior is contagious: social proof and imitation can overwhelm individual judgment
- 2Manias repeat across eras because human incentives and emotions repeat
- 3Narratives ('new era', 'can't lose', 'everyone is getting rich') often matter more than facts at the peak
- 4Broad participation + easy money + leverage tends to accelerate bubbles
- 5During manias, people rationalize rising prices as evidence of truth rather than as a symptom
- 6After the break, the crowd's "certainty" flips - panic selling mirrors panic buying
- 7Humans recover from collective madness slowly (and typically only after pain and time)
- 8Financial bubbles are one instance of a broader pattern: mass delusions are not limited to markets
Frameworks (3)
Case Studies (3)
The Mississippi Scheme
Takeaway
Financial engineering + speculative fever can lift prices far beyond reality; the unwind punishes late entrants and leverage.
The South Sea Bubble
Takeaway
Prestige, politics, and public excitement can substitute for fundamentals - until confidence breaks and liquidity disappears.
The Tulip Mania
Takeaway
Status goods + speculation can create absurd pricing narratives; treat colorful anecdotes as lessons, not precise data.
Notable Quotes
“Men, it has been well said, think in herds; ... they go mad in herds.”
“Sober nations have all at once become desperate gamblers...”
Mental Models
- —Moral epidemics (beliefs spreading like contagion)
- —Herding and social proof
- —Narrative dominance over evidence near extremes
- —Reflexive loops (belief -> action -> price -> stronger belief)
- —Status competition (keeping up with the crowd)
- —Post-peak shame/denial (slow acceptance of reality)
Key Terms
No glossary terms documented for this book.
Limitations & Caveats
Keep in mind
- •Not an investing instruction manual (no portfolio construction, valuation modeling, or security selection process)
- •Old prose + journalistic storytelling can make it slower to extract actionable rules
- •Some historical accounts - especially the Tulip Mania - are widely criticized as exaggerated or overstated in scale/impact
- •Best treated as a behavioral lens, not a fact-perfect historical source for every episode
Reading Guide
Priority Reading
- The Mississippi Scheme
- The South Sea Bubble
- The Tulip Mania
- Skim other 'delusions' for pattern recognition (social contagion mechanics)
Optional Sections
- —Non-financial delusions if you only care about markets (but they are useful for psychology)
Ratings
Concept Tags
Ready to apply these frameworks?
See concepts from this book applied to real companies with moat scores and segment analysis.
View the moat stocks listLooking for more reading?
Explore our curated collection of investing books organized by level and strategy.
Browse more booksCuration & Accuracy
This directory blends AI‑assisted discovery with human curation. Entries are reviewed, edited, and organized with the goal of expanding coverage and sharpening quality over time. Your feedback helps steer improvements (because no single human can capture everything all at once).
Details change. Pricing, features, and availability may be incomplete or out of date. Treat listings as a starting point and verify on the provider’s site before making decisions. If you spot an error or a gap, send a quick note and I’ll adjust.