VOL. XCIV, NO. 247
BOOK BREAKDOWN
NO ADVICE
Saturday, January 17, 2026
Intermediate · 2015
Irrational Exuberance
by Robert J. Shiller · Partly Dated
A behavioral + empirical explanation of why asset bubbles form, why valuations matter for long-horizon returns, and why narratives and social contagion can push prices far from fundamentals.
Level
Intermediate
Strategies
4 types
Frameworks
4 frameworks
Rating
Target Audience
Ideal Reader
- Long-horizon investors who want a bubble-literacy framework (and how to avoid getting sucked in)
- Anyone using valuation metrics (like CAPE) and wants the behavioral + historical context
- Portfolio builders who need a disciplined way to think about expected returns when markets feel euphoric
- Investors trying to understand housing cycles and bond/stock valuation regimes at a big-picture level
May Not Suit
- Readers looking for a stock-picking playbook or company analysis checklist
- Short-term traders looking for timing signals
- Anyone who wants a single mechanical indicator that reliably calls tops and bottoms
Investor Fit
| Strategy | Behavioral Finance · Macro/Global · Portfolio Management · Quantitative |
| Time Horizon | Long-term (5+ years) |
| Asset Focus | Equities · Real Assets · Fixed Income · Multi-Asset |
| Math Level | Basic Arithmetic |
| Prerequisites | Comfort with basic valuation ratios (P/E, dividend yield) · Basic understanding of inflation and real vs nominal values |
Key Learnings
- 1Speculative bubbles can be fueled by feedback loops: past price increases create stories, excitement, and broader participation
- 2Investor psychology spreads socially (contagion): people copy others, chase status, and fear missing out
- 3Valuation matters most over long horizons; high starting valuations imply lower forward returns (timing is hard)
- 4Markets can stay irrational longer than your patience/liquidity; bubble detection is not bubble timing
- 5Inflation-adjusted (real) series change how you see markets - nominal new highs can mislead
- 6Housing and bonds can exhibit the same speculative dynamics as stocks
- 7Bubbles are not only about greed; they are often about narratives that feel rational in the moment
- 8The practical response is risk control: diversification, avoiding leverage, and a plan that does not depend on predicting turning points
Frameworks (4)
Formulas (3)
Case Studies (3)
Late-1990s / 2000 stock market boom
Takeaway
Narratives plus feedback can push equities to historically extreme valuations; the unwind can take years and is hard to time.
U.S. housing boom and bust
Takeaway
Real estate is not always safe; leverage and belief-driven price dynamics can create bubble-like outcomes.
Post-2008 multi-asset pricing (stocks + bonds + housing)
Takeaway
Multiple markets can become richly priced at the same time; risk management matters more than clever forecasting.
Mental Models
- —Psychological contagion (social transmission of excitement and belief)
- —Feedback loop / reflexivity (price increases -> more buying -> higher prices)
- —Narrative-driven investing (stories as a driver of demand and expectations)
- —Real vs nominal thinking (inflation-adjusted reality vs money illusion)
- —Valuation as long-horizon gravity (useful for expected returns, weak for timing)
- —Regime humility (relationships shift; indicators have error bars)
Key Terms
No glossary terms documented for this book.
Limitations & Caveats
Keep in mind
- •Bubble identification is not reliable timing; markets can remain expensive/cheap for long stretches
- •CAPE and related metrics have known issues (backward-looking, accounting changes, payout changes like buybacks)
- •Narratives and psychology are real drivers but hard to measure cleanly; there is unavoidable subjectivity
- •Macro regimes (inflation, rates, policy) can shift the baseline for normal valuation
Related Tools
Reading Guide
Priority Reading
- Bubble definition and historical perspective
- Behavioral/narrative drivers of speculative markets
- Valuation measures (including CAPE) and long-horizon implications
- Cross-market discussion (stocks, housing, bonds in newer editions)
Optional Sections
- —Very edition-specific market commentary if you only want the durable mental models
Ratings
Concept Tags
Ready to apply these frameworks?
See concepts from this book applied to real companies with moat scores and segment analysis.
View the moat stocks listLooking for more reading?
Explore our curated collection of investing books organized by level and strategy.
Browse more booksCuration & Accuracy
This directory blends AI‑assisted discovery with human curation. Entries are reviewed, edited, and organized with the goal of expanding coverage and sharpening quality over time. Your feedback helps steer improvements (because no single human can capture everything all at once).
Details change. Pricing, features, and availability may be incomplete or out of date. Treat listings as a starting point and verify on the provider’s site before making decisions. If you spot an error or a gap, send a quick note and I’ll adjust.