VOL. XCIV, NO. 247
★ WIDE MOAT STOCKS & COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGES ★
PRICE: 0 CENTS
O'Reilly Automotive, Inc.
ORLY · Nasdaq Global Select Market
Weighted average of segment moat scores, combining moat strength, durability, confidence, market structure, pricing power, and market share.
Request update
Spot something outdated? Send a quick note and source so we can refresh this profile.
Overview
O'Reilly Automotive is a specialty retailer and distributor of automotive aftermarket parts serving both DIY consumers and professional service providers via a dual-market strategy. The core moat is operational: a scaled, tiered distribution and store network supporting high parts availability and rapid replenishment. On the professional side, dedicated sales coverage, delivery capability, and proprietary ordering/catalogn tools deepen relationships with repair shops. Key pressures include intense price competition, online and marketplace alternatives, and the risk that peers replicate service levels and supply chain advantages.
Primary segment
DIY Aftermarket Retail
Market structure
Oligopoly
Market share
—
HHI: —
Coverage
2 segments · 8 tags
Updated 2025-12-31
Segments
DIY Aftermarket Retail
Specialty automotive aftermarket parts retail (DIY channel)
Revenue
52%
Structure
Oligopoly
Pricing
moderate
Share
—
Peers
Professional (B2B) Aftermarket Distribution
Automotive aftermarket parts distribution to professional service providers (repair shops, fleets, body shops)
Revenue
48%
Structure
Competitive
Pricing
moderate
Share
—
Peers
Moat Claims
DIY Aftermarket Retail
Specialty automotive aftermarket parts retail (DIY channel)
Revenue share reflects the company's FY2024 sales mix disclosure for DIY customers.
Supply Chain Control
Supply
Supply Chain Control
Strength
Durability
Confidence
Evidence
Tiered distribution (DCs + Hub stores) plus inventory and routing systems improve in-stock rates and speed for hard-to-find parts, supporting repeat purchases and reducing stockouts versus smaller competitors.
Erosion risks
- Competitor distribution networks narrowing the service gap
- E-commerce and rapid last-mile delivery reducing advantage of local stocking
- Supply chain disruptions increasing out-of-stocks
Leading indicators
- In-stock and fill-rate metrics (if disclosed)
- Comparable store sales vs peers
- Gross margin trend vs peers
Counterarguments
- Large peers (e.g., AutoZone, NAPA/GPC) also operate scaled distribution networks, limiting uniqueness
- Some DIY demand can be satisfied by fast-shipping online competitors for non-urgent parts
Physical Network Density
Supply
Physical Network Density
Strength
Durability
Confidence
Evidence
A large store footprint and clustered site strategy support convenience and local availability, which matters for urgent repairs and immediate DIY needs.
Erosion risks
- Foot traffic migration to online ordering and delivery
- Rising labor/rent costs pressuring store economics
- Shrink and inventory carrying costs
Leading indicators
- Net store openings and closures
- Comparable store traffic trends
- E-commerce share and buy-online-pickup-in-store adoption
Counterarguments
- Omnichannel offerings and rapid delivery reduce the need for extremely dense physical footprints
- Mass merchants and online marketplaces can undercut on price for common parts and accessories
Brand Trust
Demand
Brand Trust
Strength
Durability
Confidence
Evidence
Service reputation is reinforced by technically trained staff and in-store service programs (testing, diagnostic support, tool loaners), which can increase conversion and repeat DIY business.
Erosion risks
- Inability to hire/retain skilled staff reduces service differentiation
- Brand damage from quality issues, warranty disputes, or poor service experiences
- Increasing consumer price sensitivity
Leading indicators
- Store labor turnover and wage pressure
- Customer satisfaction / reviews (external tracking)
- Warranty and return rates (if disclosed)
Counterarguments
- For many DIY purchases, customers are primarily price-driven and can switch retailers easily
- Online forums, videos, and diagnostics reduce the value of in-store expertise for some buyers
Habit Default
Demand
Habit Default
Strength
Durability
Confidence
Evidence
A loyalty program can increase repeat purchases, but switching costs for DIY customers remain low.
Erosion risks
- Competitors matching/boosting loyalty incentives
- Promotional intensity training customers to price-shop
- Consumer migration to marketplace ecosystems
Leading indicators
- Promotional and discount intensity
- Repeat-customer frequency (if disclosed)
- Comparable store sales stability through cycles
Counterarguments
- Loyalty programs are easy to replicate and often do not create durable switching costs
- Customers may multi-home across retailers depending on price/availability
Scope Economies
Supply
Scope Economies
Strength
Durability
Confidence
Evidence
Shared store, distribution, and inventory infrastructure supports serving both DIY and professional customers in the same footprint, improving asset utilization and enabling viable operations in a wider range of market densities.
Erosion risks
- Channel-specific competitors specializing and outperforming on either DIY or pro
- Higher complexity and cost-to-serve from supporting two customer types
- Regime shift toward online ordering reducing store-based synergies
Leading indicators
- DIY vs pro sales mix trend
- Store labor productivity (sales per employee)
- Distribution/network capex relative to sales growth
Counterarguments
- A single footprint serving both channels may be suboptimal if each channel requires different merchandising and service models
- Peers also pursue dual-channel strategies, reducing differentiation
Professional (B2B) Aftermarket Distribution
Automotive aftermarket parts distribution to professional service providers (repair shops, fleets, body shops)
Revenue share reflects the company's FY2024 sales mix disclosure for professional service provider customers.
Service Field Network
Supply
Service Field Network
Strength
Durability
Confidence
Evidence
A dedicated professional sales force, territory coverage, and delivery/service specialists increase account penetration and responsiveness for repair shops, supporting repeat B2B ordering.
Erosion risks
- Repair shops shifting orders to fully digital platforms
- Repair shop consolidation increasing buyer power
- Competitors matching delivery cadence and account service levels
Leading indicators
- Professional customer sales growth vs DIY
- Sales staff productivity (sales per rep, if disclosed)
- Delivery speed/frequency and fulfillment performance
Counterarguments
- Professional customers often multi-source based on price and immediate availability
- Many competitors (including independents) can provide high-touch local service
Supply Chain Control
Supply
Supply Chain Control
Strength
Durability
Confidence
Evidence
Fast replenishment and broad SKU access (DC + Hub tiering, multiple deliveries) supports 'parts availability' as a win factor for professional accounts where downtime is costly.
Erosion risks
- Competitor network expansion and fulfillment improvements
- Transportation and labor cost inflation reducing service advantage
- Macro-driven inventory reductions harming fill rates
Leading indicators
- Fill rates and backorder levels (if disclosed)
- Professional gross margin and delivery cost trends
- Inventory turns and working capital intensity
Counterarguments
- The big national competitors also have sophisticated distribution networks and can match availability in major markets
- Some professional customers prioritize price over near-perfect availability
Procurement Inertia
Demand
Procurement Inertia
Strength
Durability
Confidence
Evidence
Pro ordering tools (proprietary e-commerce and mobile ordering), integrated catalog systems, and embedded programs (training, shop tools/programs) can create workflow stickiness and reduce the odds of switching primary suppliers.
Erosion risks
- Third-party shop management systems enabling easy multi-sourcing
- Online marketplaces and B2B aggregators improving catalog accuracy and delivery speed
- Open standards/APIs reducing dependence on any single distributor's tools
Leading indicators
- Adoption of digital ordering for professional accounts (if disclosed)
- Professional customer retention and frequency metrics (if disclosed)
- Growth in third-party parts procurement platforms
Counterarguments
- Most repair shops can switch suppliers with minimal friction and often keep multiple vendor accounts
- Catalog and ordering tools are increasingly commoditized and available from many distributors
Evidence
31 DCs ... 396 Hub stores.
The company describes a large, tiered distribution footprint designed to provide same-day/overnight access to a broad SKU base and enable inventory optimization.
The company discloses thousands of stores across the U.S. (and additional stores in Mexico and Canada) and describes clustering to drive distribution and advertising efficiencies.
The company emphasizes technically proficient store personnel with ongoing training and highlights multiple in-store service offerings supporting DIY repair completion.
The company describes its O'Rewards loyalty program as encouraging repeat customers via points redeemable for rewards.
52% ... DIY ... 48% ... professional.
The filing describes the dual-market strategy and discloses the approximate DIY vs professional sales mix, supporting the scope/asset-sharing thesis.
Showing 5 of 8 sources.
Risks & Indicators
Erosion risks
- Competitor distribution networks narrowing the service gap
- E-commerce and rapid last-mile delivery reducing advantage of local stocking
- Supply chain disruptions increasing out-of-stocks
- Foot traffic migration to online ordering and delivery
- Rising labor/rent costs pressuring store economics
- Shrink and inventory carrying costs
Leading indicators
- In-stock and fill-rate metrics (if disclosed)
- Comparable store sales vs peers
- Gross margin trend vs peers
- DC/Hub expansion cadence and capex intensity
- Net store openings and closures
- Comparable store traffic trends
Curation & Accuracy
This directory blends AI‑assisted discovery with human curation. Entries are reviewed, edited, and organized with the goal of expanding coverage and sharpening quality over time. Your feedback helps steer improvements (because no single human can capture everything all at once).
Details change. Pricing, features, and availability may be incomplete or out of date. Treat listings as a starting point and verify on the provider’s site before making decisions. If you spot an error or a gap, send a quick note and I’ll adjust.