VOL. XCIV, NO. 247
★ BEST INVESTING TOOLS COMPARISON ★
NO ADVICE
Sunday, May 31, 2026
Tool Comparison · Sunday, May 31, 2026
Magic Formula Investing vs Value Investors Club (VIC)
Magic Formula Investing vs Value Investors Club (VIC): which investing tool fits your workflow? Compare pricing, features, platforms, and verdict in seconds.
Magic Formula Investing
magicformulainvesting.com
Best for screeners
- Pricing
- Free
- Platforms
- Web
Value Investors Club (VIC)
valueinvestorsclub.com
Best for forums
- Pricing
- Free
- Platforms
- Web
Outbound links may include affiliate or sponsor codes.
Comparison snapshot
Who should choose which?
Choose
Magic Formula Investing if…
- You’re just getting started and want an approachable UI
- You need straightforward screener with only two inputs: minimum market cap (usd, millions) and number of results (30 or 50).
- You need universe restricted to u.s.-listed equities, excluding financial and utility companies.
- You need ranks companies on two factors: high earnings yield (low p/e) and high return on capital, with minor accounting adjustments.
Choose
Value Investors Club (VIC) if…
- You need selective membership: applicants must submit a current idea to be considered for complete, no-delay access.
- You need members are required to post at least two ideas per year (up to six) and rate 20 ideas annually to maintain access.
- You need each idea has its own discussion thread, with members able to mark certain comments as private (visible to members only).
- You need guest users can browse delayed content: free email signup grants access to 45-day-old ideas; complete access requires an accepted application.
Consider alternatives if…
- You want broader category coverage in one tool.
- Neither pricing tier fits your budget.
Side-by-side feature breakdown
| Attribute | Magic Formula Investing | Value Investors Club (VIC) |
|---|---|---|
Asset types | Stocks | StocksBonds |
Experience | BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced | IntermediateAdvanced |
Regions | North America | Not specified |
Data freshness | End of Day | Not specified |
API access | Not specified | Not specified |
Export formats | Not specified | Not specified |
Seen enough? Open either tool and try it now.
Pricing breakdown
Tool
Magic Formula Investing
—
Starting price
Plans & pricing
Tool
Value Investors Club (VIC)
—
Starting price
Plans & pricing
Coverage overlap
Community category leaders
Vote sentiment comparison
Loading sentiment chart...
Still deciding? Get hands-on with both — most plans offer a free tier or trial.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the difference between Magic Formula Investing and Value Investors Club (VIC)?
Magic Formula Investing focuses on Screeners, and Stock Ideas while Value Investors Club (VIC) specializes in Stock Ideas, and Forums. They overlap in 1 categories, so choose based on your preferred workflow and pricing.
How much do Magic Formula Investing and Value Investors Club (VIC) cost?
Good news—both Magic Formula Investing and Value Investors Club (VIC) offer free plans. You can try each platform without commitment and only pay when you need premium features.
Which is better for beginners—Magic Formula Investing or Value Investors Club (VIC)?
Magic Formula Investing is more beginner-friendly with an approachable interface. Both can work for intermediate users.
Should I choose Magic Formula Investing or Value Investors Club (VIC)?
Choose Magic Formula Investing if you need Straightforward screener with only two inputs: minimum market cap (USD, millions) and number of results (30 or 50)., and Universe restricted to U.S.-listed equities, excluding financial and utility companies.. Go with Value Investors Club (VIC) if Selective membership: applicants must submit a current idea to be considered for complete, no-delay access., and Members are required to post at least two ideas per year (up to six) and rate 20 ideas annually to maintain access. better fits how you invest.
What asset classes do Magic Formula Investing and Value Investors Club (VIC) cover?
Both cover Stocks. Value Investors Club (VIC) adds coverage for Bonds.
Which has a better stock screener—Magic Formula Investing or Value Investors Club (VIC)?
Magic Formula Investing includes a stock screener for finding investment ideas. Value Investors Club (VIC) focuses on other analytical tools.
Other tools you might like
These profiles share overlapping coverage with both sides of this matchup.
Keep Exploring
Global rankings of the highest-rated tools across all categories.
Ranked list of companies with durable competitive advantages.
Proven models entering their growth phase with solid economics.
Track votes, sentiment, and engagement across the community.
Learn moat types, red flags, and real-company examples.
Browse other head-to-head tool comparisons and alternatives.
Curation & Accuracy
This directory blends AI‑assisted discovery with human curation. Entries are reviewed, edited, and organized with the goal of expanding coverage and sharpening quality over time. Your feedback helps steer improvements (because no single human can capture everything all at once).
Details change. Pricing, features, and availability may be incomplete or out of date. Treat listings as a starting point and verify on the provider’s site before making decisions. If you spot an error or a gap, send a quick note and I’ll adjust.